Flagler Avenue Pizza Company in New Smyrna Beach

South of New York you won't find better pizza. This is a casual place with a great staff close to the beach. There are always parking spots on the side road. Pizza by the slice so you can mix it up.

Bring from NYC I was surprised the pizza was not bad!

Delicious pizza by the slice. Had their white and it was amazing. Very large slices. Great flavor. We have been here many times and will be sure to come back!

Everytime we come from Miami to New Smyrna, this is a must!! Pizza is amazing and we're New Yorkers, so we have REALLY high pizza standards. You guys Rock.

The pizza is amazing!! If you like New Ork style this is the place

We really liked this place. They have lots of ready made pizzas and you can choose what you want by the slice and they will throw it in the oven for you. Food was great and service was really good. Prices were very reasonable and the place was clean and well kept.

Really good pizza with fresh ingredients. Similar to pizza you would find in the northeast. Pick up a free calendar, sticker or magnet when your there!

Busy because of proximity to beach, but severely understaffed. The staff on premises were rude & inattentive. Visiting from NYC with family, this is NOT "NY" or "NY Style" pizza. Our pizza was dry, hard crust, cheese burned on top, took almost 30mins for a fresh pie to come outThe vibe is your typical beach shack eatery, bathroom was gross and funky smell by back tables. I think they might be one of the very few pizza joints around here so everyone recommends it. NOT because it's good.

our kids love this pizza

Amazing pasta, amazing pizza. Definitely a place to visit every time I'm in NSB

Great food and friendly atmosphere. They also have a wheelchair life that takes them to beach view seating. Thanks for thinking of the disabled!

08-08-2020I made a big mistake ordering a pizza during Coronavirus Pandemic from them. When I went to pickup my order (masked & gloves on) I noticed, not one single employee was wearing a mask or following the CDC guide lines. As a matter of fact, “the dude” at the counter looked at me like I just came from Italy 😂 !!!There was no social distancing guide lines or they did not take any preventive measures to protect their customers from spreading the COVID-19Let’s hope none of the employees were asymptomatic ...Florida is breaking COVID-19 records right now every day!By the way, the pizza was not that great either🤷...chintzy on topping...taste mediocre...price high (after cleaning the box & reheating it to make sure no virus was attached) This is the first and last trip to this place!

Really enjoyed the pizzas here. My favorites were the Gramma pizza (mozzarella, basil, garlic, sauce) and an Alfredo tortellini pizza (yes, there was actually pasta on the pizza).

Great delicious New York style pizza. You can order it by the slice or the whole pie. They have a great selection to choose from in food and in beverage and they have a great wine selection. The service is phenomenal the place is clean everything is simple but the food is knock out of the park delicious. Myself and my niece and nephew had a great time and they were so kind and so a tentative to everything that we needed. I really strongly recommend this little pizza gem. Thanks guys for a great afternoon with my kids we will be back.😊

My first time eating here and it was great! Amd delicious! 😋 Definitely hitting up this spot again.

Cheap and quick place to grab a slice

The best pizza in Florida hands down! It's the best New York style pizza outside of New York. Worth the wait.

The palm tree pizza is so good!

Real nice place. Great pizza!

Good pizza. They seem to do a large carryout business. Small seating area with a couple of tables just outside the door.

Im from Pennsylvania and haven't had any good pizza here in Florida until now. I had the All Hands On Deck Pizza and loved every bite. Will definitely order from here again.

Really very good

The spinach n ricotta pizza is delicious. Very good crust. No boiled frankfürters on this menu. Ha

Simply amazing pizza. I tried the Cremé pizza yesterday Wow what an amazing and creative pizza. If in NSB you must stop by this place for a slice. Great spot

Fair price for a great slice. Usually places in touristy areas like this seem to over charge. Not the case here. The pizza tasted great and was the right price. I should've tried those garlic knots though.

Nice big pizzas, fast and friendly service.

Loved the Grandma and the Garlic knots. Very friendly place.

The pizza it's alright, but the best part of the attraction is the staff. Rather the family that runs the business? That old Italian vibe, where they are talking amongst each other and you can't tell weather they are arguing or not.

Amazing!! Clean. Friendly. Pizza was cooked perfectly. Couldn’t ask for better service. The cute lady behind the counter knew every pizza out and everything they had to offer. Made recommendations and all. Cheap too!

We enjoyed a slice of the very NY style pizza, both made to order . Lots of napkins were required! It was delicious !

Went to the beach yesterday and decided to try Flagler Avenue Pizza. It was very tasty and the slices were good size. I only wish it was a little cooler inside. The air conditioner seemed to be struggling. Great place for pizza though!

Authentic NY NJ style pizza on Florida...seriously! I'm from North Jersey and this is the good stuff!!

We ordered a. few slices while out one Friday night and the crust was very good. The slices were large and tasty just wished they had warmed it up a bit more. Loved all the variety of pizzas on the menu. Definitely will be coming to try out more of the menu!

Ordered the Arugula and Prosciutto pizza for delivery and it was literally disgusting. Took one bite and threw the ENTIRE pizza away. The Prosciutto looked nasty- old and gross. It smelled like fish. Shouldn't have even taken a bite. If I could give 0 starts I would. Will never order from here again. Gross gross gross.

I’m a New Yorker and this is some of the best pizza around!! Really great atmosphere. Fast service. Very clean. The bathroom is immaculate. The owner and staff are super nice. My only complaint is I wish I was closer!!

Greta pizza! I think the veg should be sliced smaller and the garlic bread is lacking but that nit picking.. it's a great place! A stromboli feeds 3 hungry adults

Very chill spot, open late, cold beer and good fresh pizza.

Omg that's good pizza. All sorts of pizza by the slice, and right off the beach!

Best NY pizza around!! The employees are the best. If we go for slices and they don't have any eggplant pizza they make it for me.

Love Flagler Avenue Pizza Company. Reasonable prices and most everything we have tried has been delicious. If you are at the beach you can drop in for a slice or order a whole pie. They have a great variety of pizza options and choices, even a simple cheese pizza is great. Also they have fantastic sandwiches and fries, we love the cheese steak sandwich.

Good pizza good prices friendly service 👌

Great pizza!! Thin strong crust with a killer sauce. We really enjoyed the clam strips as an appetizer too.

While vacationing in NSB we asked for a recommendation on a place with good pizza. We ended up here and ordered two pizzas for takeout. Once home I was so disappointed. I love pizza but this was just not quality, especially considering these pizzas are priced on the higher side. My pizza was flacid, and even bland and lacking in flavor. The worst part is my mushroom topping was very very obviously not fresh. It tasted and looked like it came straight out of a can. Overall it was a very sad pizza that looked and tasted like it was thrown together with no thought or effort. For a place that prides itself on “NY pizzas made with only the freshest high quality ingredients”, I expected a lot more, because that’s not what I received.

When we visited New Smyrna Beach I asked around who had the best pizza? Everyone I asked said Flagler Ave Pizza. I am a fan it is Perfect! Great atmosphere, great customer service, Perfect New York style pizza, public restroom, indoor seating and television. Price $

BEST PIZZA IN NSB!! Classic NY style pizza and many to choose and order from. Very convenient to walk to from the beach. I had the cheese tortellini pizza and it's phenomenal! Nice and comfortable. Definitely a hit with us. Will definitely be back here!

Great pizza. What a shame none of the employees wore masks, enforced social distancing or took any preventive measures to protect their customers from COVID-19

Bought the family dinner here tonight. It was worth the money and the time I waited for it to cook. Great food! My whole family loved the pizza tonight. We will definitely be back for more! Thank you for the great food tonight!

Try the Grandmas pizza. Soooo good

Great place to pick up a slice on the run.

Amazing pizza and staff!! Pizza was fresh and tasty. Staff was friendly and helpful. Will definitely go back